UnitedCardists.com - The forum for Cardistry, Magic, Custom Decks and All Things Playing Cards.

Räpylätassu wrote:

akicer wrote:I'd like to advise to take Charlemagne off the nomination list as it's not delivered and likely to be a scam

I have received my decks from the creator. Not a scam but the project got screwed when the customs on the Russian-Estonian border seized the decks and does not release them.

That however does not justify that the creator just stopped communicating at one point once the customs saga just kept going.

Magic Tapp wrote:

Räpylätassu wrote:

akicer wrote:I'd like to advise to take Charlemagne off the nomination list as it's not delivered and likely to be a scam

I have received my decks from the creator. Not a scam but the project got screwed when the customs on the Russian-Estonian border seized the decks and does not release them.

That however does not justify that the creator just stopped communicating at one point once the customs saga just kept going.

That is bollocks - one of my shipping addresses is in Russia thus eliminating the need for customs but I am yet to receive my order.

I fully support taking this deck off the nominations list.

sms69x wrote:

Magic Tapp wrote:

Räpylätassu wrote:

akicer wrote:I'd like to advise to take Charlemagne off the nomination list as it's not delivered and likely to be a scam

I have received my decks from the creator. Not a scam but the project got screwed when the customs on the Russian-Estonian border seized the decks and does not release them.

That however does not justify that the creator just stopped communicating at one point once the customs saga just kept going.

That is bollocks - one of my shipping addresses is in Russia thus eliminating the need for customs but I am yet to receive my order.

I fully support taking this deck off the nominations list.

I'm also waiting for my pledge. Although I don't believe this to be a scam, as some people have received their decks, the lack of communication from the creator is very scary. Thus, I also support removing this deck from the nominations list.

Adonael wrote:Submitted my votes, but I have absolutely no clue why we don't have a 'Best Use of Foil' category. We already needed it last year, and this year twice as much, it is becoming quite a common feature and the list of decks utilising it this year is staggering, hell there's already a colour category and foil is important in the same way.

MagikFingerz wrote:Besides, does anyone do it better than Lotrek? He wins enough categories as it is

PipChick wrote:

MagikFingerz wrote:

PipChick wrote:

Harvonsgard wrote:I dunno if Room17 will be elagible since it is an quasi just an updated version of last year’s winner.

Well, as per the rules of last year's DOTYs in regards to Eligible Decks;

Reissued variations/editions of established decks released prior to 2018 may be declared ineligible if no significant change(s) were made to the original design. Reprinted decks are not eligible at all.

Therefore, if this rule continues to be followed for this year's DOTYs, Room17 will unfortunately not be eligible for nomination and/or to receive an award for this year.

How about allowing decks to be voted for in, for example, Best Tuck if the deck features a new tuck? I'd be ok with that.

hmmm... true - I suppose it would qualify for the 'Best Tuck Case' category as it is a completely new tuck case and, I suppose, could potentially be eligible for other categories such as 'Best Joker' and/or 'Best Gaff/Extra Card(s)' if it did in fact feature completely new designs and not just slight variations of those exsisting in it's predecessor - Thanks for the perspective! Definitely hadn't considered that but you're absolutely right! In those instances, it should still qualify for consideration... I'll allow it!

Rules regarding eligible decks will be amended and added to for clarification of this particular point of consideration in nominating/voting for decks - stay tuned!

kem-collector wrote:I submitted and it is out of my outbox, but no confirmation yet.

Harvonsgard wrote:

kem-collector wrote:I submitted and it is out of my outbox, but no confirmation yet.

Did you pm Pip or DeckAwards?

misterharmanko wrote:Just submitted my votes.

Much more difficult this year.
Normally I have 1 or 2 decks that get the majority of my votes but this year I voted for a different deck in almost every category

theCapraAegagrus wrote:Winners submitted.