Page 3 of 8
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 10:21 am
by ecNate
Good catch on the Black Lions! I really wanted to talk about the hard choices, but since it's still open for a few more days (GET YOUR VOTES IN!) I'll hold off. For now I'll just say I found it hard to pick between decks in a lot of categories, my list was A or B or C and it was tough to pick just one. Thanks again for running this and major props to all the prize sponsors!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 3:52 pm
by Talisman
Yeah, I had a tough time between a few favorites and to put in my votes before deadline.
I almost was going to pass because it was that hard to pick.
I wish I could of put in top 3 choices in 1, 2 & 3 order.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 7:25 pm
by Mike Ratledge
It's been a great year! Kai & I agreed to take votes through Wednesday night, we had a couple people ask if they could still vote even over on Facebook, and felt it was reasonable.
That being the case, if anyone wants to shirt their vote, let us know by Wednesday!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2016 9:02 pm
by volantangel
Down to the last day or so to vote! We have even more prizes up for grabs !! Any votes stands a very very good chance of winning something !
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest FINAL DAY OF VOTING
Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2016 5:08 am
by volantangel
Voting has officially closed. Any more entries would not be accepted. Please wait for the results to be tabulated, this would take some time, so I ask for your kind patience
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2016 9:49 am
by octave
Do you have a rough number about how many took part in the contest?
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2016 11:00 am
by volantangel
octave wrote:Do you have a rough number about how many took part in the contest?
I believe there are approximately 20-25 entries this year? I need to collate the numbers, expect the results to be out in the next couple of days !
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2016 12:32 pm
by Mike Ratledge
volantangel wrote:octave wrote:Do you have a rough number about how many took part in the contest?
I believe there are approximately 20-25 entries this year? I need to collate the numbers, expect the results to be out in the next couple of days !
I think my rough count was 29, but there has to be at least one duplicate / changed entry in there, possibly two? Upper 20's, at least.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 2:19 am
by volantangel
Hmm I'm halfway though the results, I'm seeing some categories being pretty damn close, and some with clear run-away winners ! Stay tuned guys !
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 4:56 am
by octave
Wow, that sounds like really good chances of winning something
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 5:17 am
by volantangel
I believe that the final count of voters is 32! And.. I still have more than a handful of donated prizes that I have yet to include. I've found that the generousity of our members totally blowing me away !
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 12:12 pm
by Mike Ratledge
octave wrote: Wow, that sounds like really good chances of winning something
A lot of us don't vote, so everyone has a good chance of winning something. We even have a "farthest from the hole" sort of booby prize for the lowest score.
I will just go ahead and leave this here, because I can sense that Kai is about ready to post something important "really soon now"!!
- Thanks to Karin Yan for polishing it up a bit and updating it (literally) from the 2014 version!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!! (wap)
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 12:37 pm
by Cbkimble
Now Mike, you know you're supposed to vote, whether or not you include/exclude yourself from the prize pool. Everyone votes so we get more accurate winners.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!! (wap)
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 1:29 pm
by Mike Ratledge
Cbkimble wrote:Now Mike, you know you're supposed to vote, whether or not you include/exclude yourself from the prize pool. Everyone votes so we get more accurate winners.
I usually do, Brent - and DQ myself, but I've been a little distracted this year. I haven't made a lot of noise about it, but Donna had a "coronary event" that we are trying to track down.
Because the government is so messed up, Social Security / Medicare now that shes' turned 65 is all you CAN have, unless you're a millionaire I suppose. They make you jump through hoops, hoping you'll die before they pay too much money. This morning we started the journey, doing "radiology" which we all know is useless for a heart attack, except to confirm that "sumptin' don't look rat in thar", so when we were told it would be 2-3 days before we got results, needless to say her main physician calling on the phone in under 3 hours insisting that she see a cardiologist "as soon as possible" is just not a positive sign. Monday morning at 9:30 we go at it again, this time with the real doctor she needs, instead of hoop jumping.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - VOTING CLOSED!! (wap)
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 2:46 pm
by Cbkimble
Sorry to hear about that. Let her know she'll be in my prayers.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 10:03 pm
by volantangel
WINNERS ARE OUTTT !! DISCUSS AWAY ! COUNT YOUR POINTS !
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 10:19 pm
by cherrynukacola
Wow. Congratulations to all the winners. They really deserve it.
Also, extra kudos to all the great decks that didn't quite make it. It was a year overflowing with wonderful decks.
Not to get too maudlin, but everyone is a winner to me!
And edit: Looks like I scored 46! Better then last year!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 11:25 pm
by Calypso
27 points. Meh. About the same as last year, when I was brand new to this place.... go figure.
Lorenzo's decks and the Omnia campaign were better than I gave them credit for. Props to them. The one that surprised me though was that Hive didn't even place in the best tuck category. I count that LE tuck as one of my nicest.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2016 11:57 pm
by Mike Ratledge
volantangel wrote:WINNERS ARE OUTTT !! DISCUSS AWAY ! COUNT YOUR POINTS !
Awesome, and quite deserving winners all-around! Congrats to Lorenzo and Giovanni for going 1-2 in the "Best Overall" as well! It looks like all of our "best of" were indeed winners!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 12:01 am
by markjanderson
58 points if I did my math right. Much better than I thought I'd do since there were so many great decks to choose from. I was also surprised that HIVE 2 didn't get into the top 3 of any category. I thought about it for best tuck, but did have it for best use of color so a big 0 for that category. Also blew the best coin category, should have stuck with my first choice in Omnia, but changed it to Arcana -- another big 0 for that one.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 12:56 am
by nECr0MaNCeD
46 for me. Also better than last year. I was sure Branle would win for best Jokers and since I loved them I thought it was a sure win. I was surprised they didn't even place. Big goose egg there. Another surprise was Seasons didn't place for best coin and even though there were a lot of good coins this year, I thought Seasons was by far the best. Big goose egg number two.
Congrats to the winners.....
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 1:31 am
by chach
62 if I did my math correctly.
But I am on my way back from a hockey game after a few drinks.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 1:32 am
by ryansworld4
Did better then last year 33 points
, congrats to the winners.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!! (wap)
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 1:56 am
by Cbkimble
I'm figuring up 47 points. I was also surprised that the seasons coin didn't even place. I think seasons was slightly underrated this year.
Lorenzo had a magnificent year. I was a little disappointed that he wasn't in the top 3 for best series. I was almost certain that the number 17 crown edition would have locked for best tuck. Since he has another one coming out this year, hopefully, next year it will win. Congratulations!!!
Lotrek did quite well. If it hadn't have been for the unfortunate circumstances with ICONS(my apologies for re-opening a huge wound) , he would've been a lock for deck of the year and several other categories. Congrats on your winning categories.
While I'm not a huge fan of Giovanni, he did have quite a year. Congratulations!!!
Jackson had a great year with his tally to series. Congratulations!!!
I was really pleased to see Randy rack up several wins with cosmic bowling and draconians. Congratulations!!!
While I didnt back the Arcana project, it was by far the best KS campaign. Congratulations!!!
For all the other winners Congratulations!!! It was an amazing year and it keeps getting better every year.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 2:58 am
by flashcards
It looks like 38 points for me. It's only my first year collecting and I missed out on a lot of decks (Heretic, for example). I had to go with what I was familiar. I'm just happy that I wasn't totally out of sync with everyone else. Congratulations to everyone that voted and thanks to everyone that donated prizes. Speaking of which, how do we choose our tiers?
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 3:24 am
by Stockholm17
oooh! so happy for heretic!
thank you for the contest, the votes and for being a heretic backer.
I am going to repost asap
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 3:30 am
by sinjin7
Congrats to all the winners, all well-deserved. Here are some of my observations:
2015 was the year of Lorenzo, with 6 total 1st place votes, with Giovanni acquitting himself well with 4 total 1st place votes.
I felt Uusi had 2 great decks with Uusi Classic and BRuT, but they were shut out of any 1st place votes, which partially explains my relatively low point total with my ballot.
I kinda feel Seasons was overlooked as well.
I thought the No. 17 Crown Edition tuck box was a lock for Best Tuck Box. I can't believe I was wrong.
My biggest whiff was on Best Deck for Magic. For some reason, I completely forgot about Blaine's Black Lions deck....
If you voted for Omnia in every category, you would've still ended up with 33 points!
Seeing these results makes me realize how many strong decks came out in 2015.
Big thanks to Kai, Mike, and everyone else involved in producing the best playing cards contest in the world!
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 4:46 am
by Thirdway Industries
Hello guys!
I am very happy! - Thank you very much for voting Omnia, this mean much to me.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 5:00 am
by JacksandJokers
Well I've checked, double checked & even triple checked my score and I still get 47 points, pretty amazed for a first timer
Very surprised that Tendril Ascendant / Nightfall didn't get a few more votes. I guess it was so long ago most people forgot about it.
A big Congrats to all the winners and thanks to all the sponsors and to Mike & Kai for making this contest such a success.
Re: 2015 Deck of the Year Contest - Winners !!!!
Posted: Sat Mar 12, 2016 6:00 am
by Talisman
Hi guys!
If my math came out right then I got a 48.
It was tough making these choices and was surprised that Kings and Crooks coin wasn't in the top 3 though my other choice would have been Seasons.
Thought Omnia qualified for Best Deck Series...
Anyhow good luck to everyone and thanks to everyone involved in making this contest and to all who donated prizes.