Realistic deck by Ace Collectable Cards

[AceCollectable Cards]

Thanks Rich and STLBluesNut for feedback.

I have updated them and have put in the original pips back. Would love your thoughts.









The tuck box is almost complete,

Thank you

[STLBluesNut]

I guess I was kind of vague. I more meant to change the index pips to match those inside the border. The realistic ones would probably look better on the number cards too.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[Eric Lee]

Wow, thanks Justin! Now I'm really invested in seeing this get funded!

Frames look much better. Consider changing the colour of the frames to look like a classic wooden frame. It'll make it fit the theme of portraits.

I also echo RichK "Like the borders but the pips seem off. I can see the 3D depth edge on Club and Diamond easier. Not sure they look realistic."
Consider removing the 3D edge on the C and D pips. Keep the texture and see how it looks with the textured pips on both in and out of the frame.


Interesting how the QoC came out looking like an older lady compared to the QoHm ( which is right now, my fave). Was that intentional? Nice touch anyway in interpreting which court is older or younger, the personalities of the individual like the JoD being fiercer than the others. Can't wait to see all the courts and their individual personalities coming out.

[RichK]

Eric Lee,

Wooden frames would be a great look. Lets see a try Justin.

[AceCollectable Cards]

That is awesome as that is exactly what I was trying to do, to make the borders look like Wooden frames, Royal Portraits.

Here are also how the cards look with the new pips without the 3D effect.









I will definitely have a go with trying out a wooden color and perhaps awooden texture for the border frames.

Thank you

[STLBluesNut]

I like the index pips being the other fancy pips.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[AceCollectable Cards]

Hi guys,

Here is the updated card with wooden frame border.



Would love your thoughts.

Thanks

[RichK]

Looks good but I imagined a golden "wood" border like on old portraits.

[AceCollectable Cards]

Looks good but I imagined a golden "wood" border like on old portraits.

Thanks Rich, that is a brill idea! Have redone the frame completely, would love your thoughts.

[RichK]

That is a great frame Justin!

[AceCollectable Cards]

"RichK" That is a great frame Justin!

Thank you Rich

Also would love feedback on either having the same frame for all the suits or to have a different frame for each suit.








Would love your thoughts on these frames.

Thank you

[STLBluesNut]

Overall, I like the spades frame best. I think it would be good to have a different frame for each.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[Eric Lee]

Hmm... The QoS frame colour does looks good, like STLBluesNut . Perhaps consider matching the frame colour with the suit? Reddish Mahogany with the reds, while Dark Brown Walnut for the blacks?

After seeing the textured pips with the frames, some of them seem more distracting. I like the wooden clubs. So perhaps also go with a less flashy Spade, more muted but solid metal look. Heart maybe more soft, fleshy look (without being disgusting, gory?) Mute the sparkle on the diamonds a bit more?

[shimmering]

If you are adding gilded picture frames like that it starts to make them look like old fashioned portraits, I wonder whether you have tried adding a kind of dark background within the frame like such old portraits would often have. I mean like a dark brown or dark grey. I don't know whether it would work, and it's not really what I thought when I first saw the designs, but with these frames it could be worth a test.

[RichK]

Spade frame has best aging. Having different frame for each suit looks better.

[AceCollectable Cards]

I am so glad you like the frames, each suit will have a different frame.

Also will reduce the

Hmm... The QoS frame colour does looks good, like STLBluesNut . Perhaps consider matching the frame colour with the suit? Reddish Mahogany with the reds, while Dark Brown Walnut for the blacks?

After seeing the textured pips with the frames, some of them seem more distracting. I like the wooden clubs. So perhaps also go with a less flashy Spade, more muted but solid metal look. Heart maybe more soft, fleshy look (without being disgusting, gory?) Mute the sparkle on the diamonds a bit more?

No probs, will do a less flashy effect on the pips. Thank you

Would love feedback for the back of the card, thou I am thinking to make the edges around the card a clean white.

Here are a couple back of card ideas so far:

1


2


3


I was thinking to do back of card 1 with clean white edges around it.

[Eric Lee]

At last we get to see the backs! Been looking forward to it. The design overall is very nice and suits the theme. However in another thread on this sam forum, TGW mentioned about the line weight or lack of it making the courts look flat. It's the same issue here for your back. For a realistic portraits of the courts, the backs need to match the front cards as well.

Right now the back design doesn't pop as much as the front. The backs also needs to look realistic as well to fit with the theme.I'm not a designer, so I don't know the technical terms for what I'm describing.

I must confess though, that I'm comparing this deck with The Golden Age deck produced by Agitcom. That's the benchmark for me, personally right now, for realism. Take a look at the back design to see what I mean .
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/21 ... le_created

The back looks real, solid, almost like a photo. So your back would need to look more like it was a painting of a real royal crest or imperial seal. That would, for me, fit the Royal Portraits theme.

Keep surprising us!

[STLBluesNut]

I agree with Eric. I like the design over all but it needs some shading or gradients to give is a more realistic look. It appear as though it was line drawn then just filled in with color using a paint bucket. Just solid color.

Need to look more shaded and textured like the frames around the courts.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[AceCollectable Cards]

Thanks for the feedback.

I have updated the back of card.



Would love your thoughts, also would you prefer the edges of the card to be white?

Thank you so much.

Justin & Ace team

[STLBluesNut]

That is tons better! Very nice.

I would have to see the background color to really choose. Perhaps white background with the red you have being foil [emoji16]

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[STLBluesNut]

You see the top and bottom circles in blue? It looks like those end detail got cut off flat and it looks odd. In comparison, see the edges circled in green.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[AceCollectable Cards]

Thank you so much STLBluesNut.

I have improved the back of the card.



Thank you,

Justin & Ace team

[STLBluesNut]

I think that looks good. If that is a white border. I think it is too wide, but I think the design and coloring are pretty in point.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[RichK]

Like this back but white border too big.

[AceCollectable Cards]

Thanks guys

Here is the updated back of card. Will post the tuck box shortly



Thanks again

Justin & Ace team

[AceCollectable Cards]

The tuck box for the Royal Portraits deck.



With a gold metallic foil finish on the tuck box and hopefully some embossing.

Would love your thoughts.

Best wishes,

Justin & Ace team

[STLBluesNut]

I like both the back and the tuck. The tuck would look especially nice on matte with some foil. Great improvements.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

[RichK]

Great back! I think if you put a portrait in the Spade area the tuck will tie to the cards. Matte black with foil would be slick too.

[Eric Lee]

Hmm... maybe it's just me, but I prefer having the whole design kept within the black background, but make the white border thinner to compensate. I find the gold gets lost in the white.

Same goes with the middle design. Maybe consider outlining the silver with a thin black line to make it stand out more from the white background. Right now it gets lost as well in the white. Perhaps all black just to see if it make a difference and let's compare it together?

As for the tuck, make the back design bigger. This is a Royal deck, so the back design should be bigger. You want it to grab the attention like you did with the front design. Big and bold, but lacking a picture. Maybe the QoS that I like so much? Or maybe a K? Or the yet to be revealed AoS design. You could have deliberately been saving that black space for your AoS. Knock us out with that!

[AceCollectable Cards]

I like both the back and the tuck. The tuck would look especially nice on matte with some foil. Great improvements.

Sent from my Galaxy 8 using Tapatalk

Thanks STLBluesNut!, I am so glad you like, I definetly want to have a gold foil on the tuckbox.

Great back! I think if you put a portrait in the Spade area the tuck will tie to the cards. Matte black with foil would be slick too.

Thank you Richard! Matte Black is a brill idea and ALSO That was an amazing idea to add one of the cards into the spade on the tuck box, Thanks so much for this great improvement!

Hmm... maybe it's just me, but I prefer having the whole design kept within the black background, but make the white border thinner to compensate. I find the gold gets lost in the white.

Same goes with the middle design. Maybe consider outlining the silver with a thin black line to make it stand out more from the white background. Right now it gets lost as well in the white. Perhaps all black just to see if it make a difference and let's compare it together?

As for the tuck, make the back design bigger. This is a Royal deck, so the back design should be bigger. You want it to grab the attention like you did with the front design. Big and bold, but lacking a picture. Maybe the QoS that I like so much? Or maybe a K? Or the yet to be revealed AoS design. You could have deliberately been saving that black space for your AoS. Knock us out with that!

Hi Eric! I have gone with the Queen of Spades as you like. Also made the back design bigger. I hope you like it, Thanks for helping improve the deck Eric.




Thank you so much everyone for helping improve this deck. It means the world to me.

Sincerely,

Justin & Ace team